Cart is empty
Cart is empty

Thanksgiving grocery list from local makers

Twelve jars, bags & bottles to cross off early

The turkey and the produce come from your usual store. These 12 shelf-stable items from small makers can arrive weeks ahead and wait in the pantry until Thanksgiving, Thursday, Nov. 26.

A Pasta Lab bag of Gemelli pasta made with Mid-Atlantic grains, produced in Philadelphia, PA

A Thanksgiving grocery list has two halves. One is fresh: the bird, the potatoes, the cream and the greens, which you buy in the last few days. The other is everything that keeps: jams, sauces, spices, rice, pasta and molasses. That second half can be ordered now and crossed off before the week gets busy.

The 12 items below are that second half, all from small makers who sell on LocalCart. LocalCart sells no turkey, produce, meat, dairy or bread, so this list sticks to what ships at room temperature. Prices are what the site showed on Nov. 3, 2026, before shipping and tax.

Thanksgiving pantry staples to order early

Four that cover the side dishes & the day after

Start the Thanksgiving shopping list with the things that sit in a cupboard, since that part of a Thanksgiving grocery list never needs a last-minute trip. Thanksgiving pantry staples do two jobs: they fill out the side dishes on Thursday, and they turn leftovers into dinner on Friday and Saturday. Browse LocalCart's shelf-stable pantry goods for more.

  1. 1A box of small-batch dried pastaBest for baked mac and cheese
  2. 2A jollof rice premix for a second starchBest for Friendsgiving tables
  3. 3A jar of tomato sauce for the weekendBest for leftover nights
  4. 4A smoky chipotle sauce for leftover tacosBest for the Friday after

1. A box of small-batch dried pasta

For a baked pasta side, or the leftovers

Best for baked mac and cheese

Pasta Lab's Dried Pasta Box of 4 ($32.00) holds four 12 oz bags made in Philadelphia: Radiatori and Campanelle made with red spring wheat, plus Gemelli and Vesuvio made with spelt. The page says the Radiatori is a 2024 Good Food Award winner and that the pasta needs no refrigeration and is best used within 6 months.

Ridged, curly shapes like Radiatori and Campanelle hold a cheese sauce well, which makes this box a natural for a baked mac and cheese side. Save a bag for the weekend, when a pot of pasta is the easiest way to use leftover turkey.

Package of Pasta Lab Gemelli spealt pasta in clear labeled bag on gray gravel stones.

On the list

Dried Pasta, Box of 4

Pasta Lab · $32.00

Buy now

2. A jollof rice premix for a second starch

A West African rice side in about 35 minutes

Best for Friendsgiving tables

Not every table wants three kinds of potato. Amac's Easy N' Tasty Jollof Rice ($7.99) is a jasmine rice premix of the West African dish, which the page says cooks on the stovetop in 35 minutes. It comes in a mild bag and a spicy bag, both $7.99, and both bags carry a Vegan badge.

That makes it an easy side for a guest who skips the turkey and the buttered rolls. Amac is run by Maryland-based Dr. Kwamena Atta Cudjoe and his wife, Penelope.

3. A jar of tomato sauce for the weekend

Turkey meatballs or baked pasta on Saturday

Best for leftover nights

Vesta Kitchen's Sunday Kind of Love ($12.00, 16 fl oz) is a tomato sauce the maker calls great for pastas, pizzas and meatballs. On the Thanksgiving dinner side of the list it does nothing. On the leftovers side it does a lot: roll leftover turkey into meatballs, or layer it with pasta and cheese and bake it.

Vesta Kitchen is in Pottstown, PA, and also makes the two spice blends and the hot sauce further down this list, so ordering all four from one maker keeps the shipping to one charge.

4. A smoky chipotle sauce for leftover tacos

Turn day-after turkey into a taco night

Best for the Friday after

Caulfield Provision Company's Smoky Red Pepper Chipotle Sauce ($6.50, 6 oz) gets its heat from red jalapenos and chipotle powder, and the maker suggests it for tacos, eggs, fish and chili. Shredded turkey warmed in a few spoonfuls of it makes a quick taco filling the day after.

Caulfield is a woman-owned, family-run business in Potomac, MD.

Red pepper chipotle sauce from Caufield in a glass bottle with bold label and spicy flavor blend.

On the list

Smoky Red Pepper Chipotle Sauce

Caulfield Provision Company · $6.50

Buy now

Thanksgiving appetizers & a cheese board

Something to eat while the turkey rests

Thanksgiving appetizers should be easy, because the oven is busy. A block of cheese, a jar of something sweet and a few salty bites will hold guests until dinner. A Thanksgiving charcuterie board is mostly a fresh-food job (cheese, cured meat, fruit), so the jars below fill the gaps between them.

  1. 5Hot pepper jelly over cream cheeseBest for the first guests at the door
  2. 6Two sweet jars for the cheese boardBest for a grazing board
  3. 7Smoked pickled eggs for the salty cornerBest for boards with no time for deviled eggs
  4. 8A flower syrup kit for a welcome drinkBest for hosts who want one signature drink

5. Hot pepper jelly over cream cheese

The two-minute cracker spread

Best for the first guests at the door

Hot pepper jelly spooned over a cold block of cream cheese is the classic starter that needs no oven. The jar here is Loudounberry pepper jam, sold as Hotter 'N' Hell Pepper Jam ($4.99, 10 oz), whose label lists vinegar, sugar, pectin, mixed peppers, spices and citric acid.

Set it out with sturdy crackers. Cream cheese is perishable, and the FDA's 2-hour rule says to discard perishable food left out more than 2 hours, so put out half a block and refill it from the fridge.

Pepper jam jar from Loudounberry Farm, with visible pepper chunks and a simple white label and gold lid.

On the list

Hotter 'N' Hell Pepper Jam

Loudounberry Farm & Garden · $4.99

Buy now

6. Two sweet jars for the cheese board

Fruit jelly beside the sharp cheese

Best for a grazing board

A board needs something sweet next to the aged cheddar and the salty meat. Loudounberry's Huckleberry Jelly ($5.99, 10 oz) lists huckleberry juice, sugar, pectin and citric acid. For a bigger jar, its Muscadine Jam ($4.99) shows a 19 oz jar labeled Muscadine Jelly, made with muscadine juice and cane sugar.

Give each jar its own small spoon. Once open, both labels say to refrigerate, and the National Center for Home Food Preservation advises keeping opened jams and jellies at 40°F or lower.

7. Smoked pickled eggs for the salty corner

A deviled-egg shortcut, already seasoned

Best for boards with no time for deviled eggs

Loudounberry's Smoked Pickled Eggs ($5.99) come in a 32 fl oz jar. Halve them and add a pinch of salt and paprika, and they take the spot deviled eggs usually fill, with no boiling or peeling on a busy morning.

Treat them like any egg dish on the table and keep them cold until serving, then follow the same 2-hour limit as the cheese.

Pickled eggs in a large glass jar from Loudounberry Farm, labeled smoked and packed in brine.

On the list

Smoked Pickled Eggs

Loudounberry Farm & Garden · $5.99

Buy now

8. A flower syrup kit for a welcome drink

A non-alcoholic pour for every guest

Best for hosts who want one signature drink

Floral Elixir's The Botanist ($32.00) is a kit of five 2 oz flower syrups (Lemon Verbena, Jasmine, Rose Hip, Juniper Berry and Prickly Pear) with at least 20 servings and recipes on the back of each box. The box says the syrups are non-alcoholic and made for spirits, champagne or sodas.

That covers both sides of the table: a splash in sparkling wine for some guests, a splash in seltzer for the kids and the drivers. Floral Elixir is a woman-owned maker in Cleveland, OH.

Sauces, spices & sweets for Thanksgiving side dishes

Small jars that change a familiar plate

Thanksgiving side dishes are where a single jar earns its place. Roasted sweet potatoes, green beans and greens are the same every year, and a new seasoning changes them without a new recipe. LocalCart's small-batch spice mixes are a good place to start.

  1. 9A sweet & smoky rub for roasted sweet potatoesBest for sweet potatoes & carrots
  2. 10A furikake blend for green beansBest for a new take on green beans
  3. 11A garlic hot sauce for the greensBest for braised greens
  4. 12Blackstrap molasses for molasses cookiesBest for bakers who like a strong cookie

9. A sweet & smoky rub for roasted sweet potatoes

Brown sugar, cumin & a little cayenne

Best for sweet potatoes & carrots

Vesta Kitchen's Sugar & Spice ($10.00, 2.5 oz) lists brown sugar, onion powder, cumin, kosher salt, black pepper, paprika, chili powder, garlic powder and cayenne. The maker calls it a rub for pork, chicken and grilled vegetables.

Toss sweet potato or carrot wedges in oil and a spoonful of the rub, then roast until the edges caramelize. The label says Gluten Free and Vegan.

Sugar & Spice Proprietary Spice Blend

On the list

Sugar & Spice Spice Blend

Vesta Kitchen · $10.00

Buy now

10. A furikake blend for green beans

Sesame, nori & a salty crunch

Best for a new take on green beans

Vesta's Brand New Funk ($10.00, 2.5 oz) is a furikake-style blend of bonito flakes, sesame, nori, almond, fermented chile powder and salt. Shake it over roasted green beans or Brussels sprouts right before serving so it stays crisp.

Check your guest list first: bonito is a fish and almond is a tree nut, so it does not suit a vegetarian or nut-free plate.

11. A garlic hot sauce for the greens

A few dashes for collards or kale

Best for braised greens

A few dashes of hot sauce are a common finish for braised greens. Vesta's Garlic Blues Fermented Hot Sauce ($12.00, 5 fl oz) is fermented with a lot of garlic and, in the maker's words, a bit less spicy, very aromatic and smooth.

Put the bottle on the table rather than in the pot, so each guest sets their own heat.

12. Blackstrap molasses for molasses cookies

The darkest, boldest kind, so check your recipe

Best for bakers who like a strong cookie

Molasses cookies are the dessert-table cookie that keeps for days. McCutcheon's Blackstrap Molasses ($3.45, 21 oz) is made in Frederick, MD, and its label calls it crude, unsulphured and strong in flavor, and says it is perfect for baking.

Check what your recipe asks for before you swap it in. Wikipedia's molasses overview explains that blackstrap comes from a third boiling of the sugar syrup and that its bitterness is much greater than that of regular molasses. If the recipe just says molasses, blackstrap will give a darker, less sweet and more bitter cookie, so bake a test batch first.

Blackstrap molasses jar from McCutcheon’s with classic label and metal lid for traditional sweetening.

On the list

Blackstrap Molasses

McCutcheon's · $3.45

Buy now

When to order from local online grocery delivery

Order the jars now, the turkey later

Split your Thanksgiving dinner list in two. Write the fresh items (turkey, produce, dairy, bread) on one side and buy them in the final days from a store near you. Put the shelf-stable items on the other side and order them first, because they wait in a cupboard as well as on a store shelf.

If you searched for local online grocery delivery, know what LocalCart is before you order. It is a marketplace where small makers list their own products, and each maker packs and ships its own order. It does not deliver fresh groceries from nearby stores. The local online grocery delivery catalog sorts every listing by category, from preserves to pantry goods to sauces and spices.

Shipping works per maker. A cart with items from two makers shows two shipping charges at checkout, each calculated for your address, and LocalCart's terms call the delivery times shown estimates, not guarantees. That is the main reason to order early: an estimate that slips a few days does not matter in early November, and it matters a lot on Nov. 24.

Before you check out0 of 5 done

If you want the bigger picture on buying from small producers, the USDA Economic Research Service keeps a running body of USDA research on local food sales, including estimates of market size, how farms sell direct to consumers and who buys local food.

Thanksgiving grocery list FAQs

Frequently asked questions

What should go on a Thanksgiving grocery list?

Split it into fresh and shelf-stable. Fresh: the turkey, potatoes, vegetables, butter, cream and bread. Shelf-stable: jams and jellies for the cheese board, spices for the side dishes, rice or pasta, sauces for leftovers and baking staples like molasses. Order the shelf-stable half early and buy the fresh half in the last few days.

Does LocalCart ship fresh turkey or produce?

No. LocalCart lists no turkey, meat, produce, dairy or bread, and its Meats and Baked Goods categories show Coming Soon with no products. Everything on this list is shelf-stable and ships without refrigeration, so buy the fresh food from a store near you.

How early should you order shelf-stable holiday items?

Early enough that the slowest delivery estimate shown at checkout still arrives several days before Thanksgiving, Thursday, Nov. 26. Each maker ships separately and LocalCart's estimates are not guarantees, so order the whole list at once rather than waiting until the final week.

Do jams & pickled eggs need to stay cold after opening?

Loudounberry's jam and jelly labels say Refrigerate After Opening. Keep opened jars in the fridge at 40°F or lower, and do not leave perishable foods like cream cheese and eggs out for more than 2 hours.

Can I use blackstrap molasses in any molasses cookie recipe?

You can, but expect a stronger, more bitter and less sweet cookie than a recipe made with regular molasses. If your recipe does not name blackstrap, try it in a small batch first.

Local food & small-batch shopping guides

More from the LocalCart blog

View all